Blog

The Diversity Analysis Tool (DAT): Towards better Diversity in Data for Precision Medicine

There are moral, scientific and economic reasons for having a more inclusive patient demographic represented in precision medicine. 

Precision medicine promises to provide better matches between treatments and groups of patients who have a disease and who show a set of specific traits. Better matches help ensure that a drug would be given to those who would benefit most and not be given to those who would either not be helped or would be harmed by it. A lot of attention in precision medicine focuses on powerful machine learning algorithms that can identify new sub-populations of patient groups. However, the results depend on the input data. The input data is defined by which patients are included. Deciding which patients to include in an analysis raises important ethical issues about who is and is not being best served by innovations in the field.

There are moral, scientific and economic reasons for having a more inclusive patient demographic represented in precision medicine. 


From a moral view

We want to support technologies that could benefit all of society and we want to reduce the potential harm to future patients. Including broader demographic coverage of patients means we are more likely to provide solutions that better target their needs. It also means we are better able to identify groups who would not benefit from or be harmed by a drug being developed.

From a scientific view

We know that the effectiveness of drug treatments can be influenced by a patient’s age, sex, ethnicity or other demographic factors. There are also indirect factors that are important. Race and socio-economic status lack a biological meaning, but they are linked with long-standing healthcare inequities and challenges with recruiting participants for clinical trials.

From an economic view

Having a more inclusive patient representation in precision medicine activities provides benefits on both the demand and supply sides of pharmaceuticals. On the demand side, healthcare bodies can rationalise limited financial resources to buy medicines that are most likely to work for patient groups. With wider demographic coverage in the data sources that lead to innovations, the buyers may be able to serve more people who are part of their general patient populations.  On the supply side, having more diverse data sources available will make it more likely to produce treatments that will pass clinical trials and support new patient markets.

All of these reasons address why it would be good to improve the diversity of patients represented in patient data. However, it is also important to show how diversity could be improved. The current lack of diversity in the field is recognised and widely discussed in areas of policy development, research project funding, and drug approval. 

The UK Bioindustry Association (BIA) recognises that the first step to improving data diversity is knowing how diverse acquired or available datasets are. This awareness and understanding enables the researcher to work to plug the data gap. To enable this assessment, BenevolentAI has provided a pragmatic solution:

Figure 1 - outline of what the Diversity Analysis Tool does


The program works as shown in the diagram. Suppose you are in an organisation that uses patient-level data to drive a precision medicine activity. You may link various data sets that contain the age, sex, ethnicity, race and socio-economic status of each patient. In doing so, you produce a single data set that contains these variables. The program will transform the demographic data set and use it to generate multiple graphs (see figures 2 and 3). It also generates another CSV file which groups patient records by age bands. The program can be run on its own, or you can use it as a library that you include in other programs. Before you use it, you should ensure that it will support good information governance practices.

Figure 2 - an example output showing the race and sex of samples in IPUMS USA, University of Minnesota


Figure 3 - an example output showing the educational attainment of samples in IPUMS USA, University of Minnesota, an indication of SES


This scenario we describe here oversimplifies some of the work that is typically needed to properly process demographic data. The program makes assumptions about the input data that may vary depending on the health data being used. It also only produces results for a single data set rather than trying to pool results from multiple data sets. Significant work is often needed to harmonise codes and categories for ethnicity, race and socio-economic status that vary among data sets.

The code base we have open-sourced is meant to be simple and provide some basic code examples that may inspire you to develop more sophisticated solutions. We also provide information about common data processing issues that relate to these demographic concepts. The code base may help you make a better assessment of the diversity in data sets you already work with. It may just help you evaluate the diversity in future health data sets you may encounter. However you may use the code, we hope it encourages you to think more about improving the diversity in data.

Open Source programme

The Diversity Analysis Tool is available on GitHub here

Brought to you by the BenevolentAI team: Mario Black, Monica Belich, Reubin Bhogal, Aylin Cakiroglu, Lucas Eggers, Matyas Fodor, Kevin Garwood, Alexander Gaujean, Gloria Hwang, Rajin Kang, Celine Lature, Nicholas Litombe, Alix Lacoste, Adepeju Oshisanya, Ibukunoluwa Oluwayomi, Aishaini Puvanendran, Anthony Risidore

More Posts

You Might Also Like

Blog
Transforming drug discovery with AI: how we’re building and nurturing the best talent for the job
At BenevolentAI, we are on a mission to bring life-changing medicines to patients, and we are looking for collaborative, mission-driven people to join our tech, drug discovery and business operations teams in London, Cambridge and New York.
Oct 17, 2021
News
BenevolentAI identifies novel target for ulcerative colitis and advances candidate to IND/CTA-enabling studies
BenevolentAI’s AI-Drug Discovery platform uncovered a novel target not previously linked to ulcerative colitis and advanced candidate to preclinical studies.
Oct 14, 2021
Blog
Measuring bias: moving towards more inclusive health research outcomes #stateofai
Having shared our open-source Diversity Analysis Tool last year, we were tasked to investigate and demonstrate the lack of diversity in biomedical data as part of the State of AI Report 2021.
Oct 12, 2021
Blog
Expert-augmented computational drug discovery for rare diseases
Combining scientific expertise, computational tools and our AI-enhanced biomedical knowledge graph to successfully uncover a new drug combination for treating a rare brain cancer in children.
Sep 28, 2021
News
BenevolentAI appoints Dr John Orloff to its Board of Directors
Biopharmaceutical veteran Dr John Orloff joins the BenevolentAI Board as a Non-Executive Director as it scales the development of its leading AI-derived drug pipeline.
Sep 9, 2021
Blog
AI in Drug Discovery
This blog seeks to demystify the application of artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) in drug discovery by exploring some of the challenges, opportunities and progress that has been achieved in the field so far.
Jul 13, 2021